Staying Collaborative Under Pressure
Why relational capacity matters more than communication strategies.
By Kerstin Andlaw
In many organisations, stakeholder engagement is often approached as a matter of communication; how information is shared, how expectations are managed and how messages are framed.
Yet in practice, the quality of stakeholder relationships rarely depends on communication strategies alone.
The real test often comes when tensions arise, perspectives differ, or organisations must balance collaboration with clear responsibilities and boundaries.
Across many organisations I work with, a common pattern is that difficult conversations are avoided. Attention shifts towards disagreement and winning the argument, while the relationship itself and the tensions and dynamics between people remain largely unaddressed.
Often there is an unspoken hope that these tensions will simply disappear. In reality, they are usually the very obstacle preventing common ground from emerging.
When this happens, communication can become increasingly transactional, rigid and sometimes defensive. This further deepens distance and tension because stakeholders no longer feel heard and trust begins to erode.
The familiar pattern of protecting positions then takes hold. Conversations become less open, tensions escalate, and relationships weaken.
The deeper issue is that stakeholder engagement is not primarily a communication challenge, it is a relational capacity challenge.
Trusting and effective stakeholder engagement becomes difficult when individuals or organisations lack the capacity to work constructively with tension, difference and the relationship itself.
Strong stakeholder relationships, whether internal or external, require relational capacity, the ability to:
- Listen openly and hear different perspectives
- Hold multiple viewpoints at the same time
- Attend to the relationship alongside objectives
- Maintain clarity about responsibility and boundaries
- Work constructively with tension and power dynamics
Ultimately, relational capacity means staying in dialogue and maintaining a collaborative approach even when perspectives differ or the situation feels stuck.
It is important to be clear that collaboration does not mean softening responsibility or removing clear lines.
A collaborative approach means taking responsibility for the relationship itself and strengthening commitment on both sides to the engagement process.
Sometimes this means attending to the relationship precisely in the moment when it would be easier to blame the other party for being “difficult”.
Choosing dialogue instead of blame is not a soft approach. It is an act of leadership.
TAO|ThriveAsOne worked with the Gibraltar Financial Services Commission (GFSC) over the past nine months to expand on the relational capacity of its people and strengthen stakeholder relationships within a complex regulatory environment.
The programme intentionally focused not only on tools and communication techniques, but on developing the ability to build on trust, navigate power dynamics thoughtfully, remaining constructive even when interests differ and without losing clarity on regulatory responsibilities.
How organisations show up in moments of tension ultimately determines the strength of their relational capital.
“In an increasingly dynamic regulatory landscape, the strength of our stakeholder relationships and our ability to navigate them effectively are as critical as the regulatory expectations themselves.
“What truly sets this approach apart is the close and trusted relationships we have built with firms through consistent engagement and open two-way dialogue. This has enabled a deeper, more nuanced understanding of the firms we supervise, intentionally moving away from outdated, one-size-fits-all customer service questionnaire models towards a more targeted and insight-led approach to supervision.
“The result is a more robust regulatory approach that strengthens outcomes, builds on mutual trust, and delivers lasting value for both our organisation and the stakeholders we serve.” Kerry Blight, GFSC CEO.
As part of the programme, participants developed their ability to deliberately attend to tensions within stakeholder relationships rather than remaining focused purely on content or positions.
Stakeholder relationships often involve competing priorities, organisational pressures, different interpretations of responsibility and regulatory expectations. These dynamics were a central focus of the programme.
Rather than avoiding them, participants were encouraged to develop the capacity to:
- Recognise tension without becoming defensive
- Remain curious about stakeholder pressures and perspectives
- Engage in dialogue about both the issue and the relationship when needed
- Hold firm boundaries where necessary
“At the GFSC, our regular engagement with firms is central to effective supervision, particularly in a sector as dynamic and impactful as insurance. This programme reinforced the value of clear, outcome-focused dialogue and the discipline of pausing at agreement to ask for ‘any concerns’, a simple step than can bring up any unspoken issues and help further strengthen delivery.
“It is through these deliberate practices that we continue to refine our approach and be the best that we can be in the outcomes we achieve.” Joe Perdoni, GFSC Director of Prudential and Intensive Supervision.
Collaboration is sometimes misunderstood as “giving in” or being overly accommodating. In reality, collaboration means taking shared responsibility for both the relationship and the outcome. When conversations become stuck, the most effective step is often to shift attention from arguing positions to strengthening the relationship that holds the conversation. Remaining steady in holding both the relationship and the content with clarity, empathy and boundaries is a sign of leadership maturity.
While the programme offered practical tools and techniques, developing relational capacity ultimately requires something deeper. It requires the willingness to question our own assumptions and mental models, and the courage to practise ways of engaging that may feel unfamiliar. The quality of attention and intention we bring to stakeholder relationships shapes the outcomes that follow.
Three key insights emerged from the programme:
- Dialogue builds trust
Stakeholder relationships strengthen when organisations move beyond one-way communication and create space for genuine dialogue. - Tension and resistance are valuable signals
When tensions surface, they offer an opportunity to deepen understanding and strengthen relational capital. - Clarity and collaboration go together
Clear responsibilities and expectations are strengthened not weakened by collaborative relationships.
Reflection for leaders and organisations
How does your organisation respond when stakeholder tensions arise?
Do you create space for dialogue, or move quickly to defend positions?
What capabilities might help you engage more constructively with different perspectives?
Organisations operate within networks of stakeholder relationships, and the quality of those relationships directly influences organisational effectiveness.
Strong stakeholder engagement is not built solely through processes or communication strategies. It grows from the collective relational capacity of organisations and their people to listen deeply, engage openly and navigate complexity with clarity and commitment.
In increasingly complex environments, the ability to stay in dialogue, work constructively with tension and hold both clarity and empathy is not simply a communication skill, it is a core leadership capability.
Kerstin Andlaw works with leaders and organisations on leadership, culture and stakeholder engagement. As Founder and Systemic Change Partner of TAO | ThriveAsOne Consulting, she supports organisations to build the collective capacity to work effectively within complex systems.
SHARE THIS
OTHER
Who doesn’t love a good office gossip? Hushed conversations by the coffee machine, knowing glances across the office, colleagues who "just thought you should know" – it’s all just harmless banter, right? Not quite. While gossip might seem like an inevitable part of office life, the reality is much less entertaining. Workplace backbiting can destroy trust, drain morale, and impact team productivity. Few people understand this better than Norwegian psychotherapist Glenn Rolfsen. With over two decades of experience in psychotherapy, Glenn has dedicated his career to helping businesses tackle workplace negativity head-on. His innovative "Gozzip" method has been transforming office cultures worldwide, earning him recognition at TEDx talks and WHO conferences.
Thrive catches up with Nick Pitaluga TEP, Managing Director of Gibraltar Trust & Corporate Services Limited - “GTCS”. From starting out as a messenger to leading his firm through a major merger, Nick talks about the importance of stepping outside your comfort zone and offers inspiration for anyone carving their own niche.
Fair recruitment is based on the principle that candidates are judged on their ability to do the job rather than influenced by factors such as an applicant’s gender, religion, ethnicity, or any other quality unrelated to their skills and expertise. As the Founder of Rock Learning and the Co-Founder of the ‘Count me In’ DEIB Conference, I have developed a deep understanding of the topic and how small businesses can implement inclusive hiring practices.
Whilst Brexit hasn’t exactly been a positive event, we can’t deny that it’s also been the catalyst for diversification and change. It was a true ‘before and after’ moment that made businesses rethink their strategies and, in many cases, change their direction of travel. Gibraltar’s newest bank, justbank, is born from this process. As well as heralding the arrival of a new bank, this fresh start gave the team at IDT Finance the opportunity to create innovative and tailored banking solutions from the ground up. I met with Managing Director, Damian Asquez, and Head of Corporate Banking, Nikolai Gafan, to find out more.
Two decades is a long time for any business - with all the strife that businesses large and small have had to endure these past four years, it seems that anxiety among business owners has never been higher. I recently had the pleasure of chatting with Garren Thompson, co-owner and co-founder of Gibraltar hair & beauty salon Miss Shapes, based on Bishop Rapallo’s Ramp. As the business recently hit the 20-year milestone, we discussed the highs and lows of creating a successful salon in a saturated market, how he and his team created their new range of Miss Shapes branded Hair & Beauty products and how this will help build success for another 20 years.
My name is John Hayes, and I'm a really busy guy. Busy procrastinating most of the time. You wouldn't believe how many unessential tasks I had to complete before sitting down and writing this article. Those sales reports and emails don't check themselves. Yep, I've been busy. Busy doing nothing. We've all had one of those days where we feel like we've been incredibly "busy" - but can't quite put our finger on what we actually accomplished. Maybe we spent three hours answering emails, another two fiddling with a spreadsheet no one asked for, and another hour in a meeting that could have been an email or WhatsApp message. At the end of it all, the to-do list somehow got longer, not shorter.
Artificial Intelligence promises unprecedented opportunities for small business owners in Gibraltar. As the digital landscape faces constant evolution, understanding AI becomes not just beneficial but essential for businesses aiming to thrive in 2024. In this article, we aim to demystify the complexities surrounding AI, offering an approachable guide to its fundamentals, history, and practical applications for businesses, providing you with the knowledge to embrace this technology confidently.
Pets are like family, right? As a proud cat dad, I’d actually go further and say that they are family. Over the years, I have spent my well-earned money on (many) toys, beds, treats and vet bills for my two feline furballs Nacho and Drake. And I am not alone. According to a recent Fortune Business Insight report, the global pet care market was valued at a massive £171.78 billion in 2022 and is projected to grow from £180.06 billion in 2023 to £269.29 billion by 2030.
3 mins |
How to: Brainstorm
If you’ve been dreaming of starting your own business, you’re not alone. Data from the UK’s Office for National Statistics (ONS) revealed that the annual number of companies registered is edging closer to the one million mark, that’s up by 75,000 in 2022 which itself was 30,000 higher than in 2021. Whether it's following a passion, aiming for financial independence, or breaking free from the 9-5 grind, every entrepreneurial journey begins with one crucial thing: a solid idea. But coming up with that perfect idea can be tough. This is where brainstorming comes in—it’s the creative springboard that can help you turn your business dreams into reality.
We all have bad days, right? In business, that can mean we don’t bring our A-game to work and perhaps our service slips. Maybe a dish takes too long to reach a table or a staff member sounds distracted at the till. This could lead to negative Google Reviews or on ‘that’ Facebook group that […]
Gibraltar’s size means that shoppers don’t have too far to go to shop. Schools, supermarkets, entertainment, eateries and healthcare are all within easy reach. That hasn’t stopped Gibraltar's business community from wanting to meet its customers' needs online. I met three local businesses that have embraced eCommerce.
As the CEO of a specialist security business called Paladin Defence and close protection operative/ private security contractor, I have experienced security threats of all types since 1990. From opportunistic personal attacks to targeted organised commercial crime, I feel there is a lot more we should be doing to defend and protect ourselves. Understandably, Gibraltar is considered to have a relatively low crime rate; but what are the realistic threats and risks to small businesses in our corner of the Mediterranean?
Imposter syndrome is a psychological behaviour where individuals, including many high achievers, struggle with persistent feelings of self-doubt, inadequacy, or the fear of being exposed as a fraud. Despite their achievements, those experiencing imposter syndrome believe they are undeserving of their success or worry that they've misled others into overestimating their abilities.
AI is poised to reshape the legal profession, with 31% of law firm leaders predicting major disruption by 2025. Scott Simmons explores how AI could improve client outcomes, streamline workflows, and drive value. Whether you’re cautious or curious, it’s time to explore AI’s potential.
From the increasing influence of AI to the rise of social commerce and sustainability-driven consumer demand, the key to success lies in adapting strategically rather than chasing every new trend. This guide breaks down the most impactful trends for the year ahead—offering insights on how to integrate them into your business without losing sight of what already works. Smart adaptation, not blind reinvention, is the name of the game. Here's what to expect and how to make it work for you.
Eran Shay's journey is emblematic of the modern entrepreneur. A self-confessed ‘out-of-the-box’ thinker, he swapped a successful corporate career and a senior role at Deloitte to pursue his own projects and business opportunities.
Finding someone who listens, understands, and guides you can make all the difference. For women in Gibraltar, the Women’s Mentorship Programme offers just that – honest conversations and valuable support from people with lived experience who understand. Now in its sixth cycle, the programme pairs women with mentors to help them navigate work, life, and everything in between. Ok, full disclosure: as a recently appointed mentor, that last sentence somewhat triggers the old imposter syndrome and self-doubt, but I am honoured to be part of this scheme and look forward to doing my very best in the months ahead.
In the latest edition of Thrive, regular contributor John Hayes reflects on the uncertainty facing small and medium-sized businesses in Gibraltar. From Brexit fallout to ever-changing frontier delays, he unpacks why the border remains a top concern—and how local firms are adapting. While resolving post-Brexit cross-border issues is beyond the scope of this correspondent, there are practical steps business owners can take to mitigate and manage the challenges of this uncertainty.
Running a small business is an exciting journey, but without proper bookkeeping, it can quickly become overwhelming. Imagine trying to make critical business decisions without knowing how much money is in your account or being caught off guard by a hefty tax bill because records weren’t kept up to date. Good bookkeeping isn’t just about staying compliant; it’s about gaining control over your business, planning for growth, and avoiding costly mistakes.
After teaching in schools for 18 years I decided to take the plunge and embark on a self-employed life. Driven by my passion for teaching children with special educational needs I set out to discover alternative ways to make education accessible to all. My vision was to have the individual in mind, with their own strengths and challenges, and with that came the birth of ‘edYOUcation Clare Francis’; bringing the YOU into learning.