Untangling Brexit: A postcard from Northern Ireland
June marks nine years since the UK voted to leave the European Union. I remember the exact moment I read the headline ‘UK Votes to Leave the EU’ on my phone and the feeling of shock that started to set in. My first thought was, “Er, now what?” Little did I know I would still be asking that question nine years later… Nine years of uncertainty, negotiations, grace periods, frameworks, and meticulously crafted non-statements. But still no solution.
And I don’t mean to trivialise what we all know is a highly complex, highly sensitive negotiation, but it is hard to keep optimistic at times. One man who can certainly relate to this feeling is Roger Pollen. Roger is the Head of the Federation of Small Businesses (FSB) in Northern Ireland which represents around 6,000 members from diverse sectors. I met him the day after his Brexit-themed keynote speech at the GFSB’s 2024 Annual Dinner, during which he delivered a realistic, but optimistic address on how Northern Ireland’s small businesses made it through the post-Brexit landscape.
The Brexit Vote and Its Aftermath
The 2016 UK Referendum saw Northern Ireland voting 56% to remain in the EU, in contrast to Gibraltar’s overwhelming will to stay within the EU with 96% voting remain. Despite these differences, the collective decision was to leave the EU, leading to inevitable separation without a clear plan. The collapse of the Northern Ireland Executive in 2017 further complicated matters, placing the burden on businesses to navigate the uncertain landscape.
According to Roger, FSB Northern Ireland actively engaged with its members through focus groups and policy teams to understand their ambitions and concerns. The outcome was a vision of Northern Ireland as a unique entity capable of leveraging its position between the EU and the UK. This ambitious vision was captured in two policy papers, envisioning Northern Ireland as the ‘Singapore of the Western Hemisphere’, with access to both markets.
Shaping the Debate and Overcoming Challenges
With no Executive ministers, FSB Northern Ireland took the lead in shaping the debate. Roger highlighted their extensive engagement with political leaders, UK Cabinet Members, and the media to keep the issues at the forefront. This proactive approach was necessary to address the numerous challenges posed by the Northern Ireland Protocol (NIP), which Ministers promised would operate without checks on goods between Great Britain and Northern Ireland but quickly proved problematic.
According to Roger, “The border between the EU and Ireland actually exists in the ports in Northern Ireland, which I think is a source of friction and irritation as well, because effectively, it’s Northern Ireland having to impose rules and restrictions on itself that it doesn’t necessarily want. So, if you imagine a lorry load of product coming in from Scotland into Northern Ireland destined for supermarkets to be sold in Northern Ireland, that has to be compliant with the rules of the European Union’s single market or it has to have a very good and clear set of restrictions around it to ensure that it can’t go into that market.
The Sticking Plaster Approach
Roger explained that the initial relief among business owners soon gave way to frustration as the transition period ended in 2020, bringing a slew of bureaucratic hurdles. From second-hand car prices to food safety checks, businesses faced a barrage of issues requiring ‘sticking plaster’ solutions, often termed Grace Periods. These temporary measures, while sometimes effective, highlighted the underlying instability of the NIP.
Roger further elaborated, “That border also has a significance because of the history of the Troubles in Northern Ireland, so there was a general sense that it shouldn’t be reinforced, reinstated, as a hard border where you would check things like customs and identity and so on. “So as a result of that, there was a move to manage the border somewhere else and that ended up being in the Irish Sea between Great Britain and Northern Ireland. It’s there to affect the goods that come into Northern Ireland because they’re deemed to be at risk of going into the EU through Northern Ireland.”
Engaging with Political Entities: A Delicate Balance
FSB Northern Ireland maintained a politically neutral stance, engaging with all parties to advocate for their members’ needs. Roger emphasised that this balanced approach was essential in a region marked by Unionist versus Nationalist politics, ensuring that all business cohorts, especially those most adversely affected, were represented.
Roger’s advice to Gibraltar was clear: “The challenge is to try and envisage what a good future would look like, so you know what you’re working towards. Otherwise, there’s always the temptation to resist things being suggested and proposed rather than having a vision of what you’re actually trying to get to. So when we assessed our market, we identified what we call five cohorts of businesses affected by the protocol. The first cohort was the ones for whom the protocol worked well, like the farming sector. The second cohort was those largely unaffected, like services. The third cohort was largely unaware because they were so small and they got their supplies from somebody in Northern Ireland doing the process for them. The fourth cohort was people protected by grace periods, and the fifth cohort was the ones who were badly affected. When we mapped it out like that and put the focus on the fifth cohort, we realised we couldn’t afford for anybody to be left behind. That started to give us a sense of focusing on what we needed to do.”
Looking Ahead: Potential and Caution
Roger pointed out that the evolving nature of post-Brexit regulations means that Northern Ireland and Gibraltar must remain adaptable. Northern Ireland’s unique access to the EU and UK markets positions it for potential economic resurgence. However, the need for continued advocacy and innovative solutions, such as the proposed Regulatory Compliance Certification Service (RCCS), remains critical.
While Roger acknowledged that “Post-Brexit business is good. By certain metrics, it is very good. There’s quite a lot of confidence, things are going well,” he also noted the need for growth. “In Northern Ireland, there’s X number of people who will start a new business every year per 10,000 population. In England, that’s 2X and in America, it’s 5X. So five times more people per 10,000 in America will start a business this year than in Northern Ireland. Our economy is pretty much treading water. We would typically have a business birth rate of about 10% and a business death rate of about 10%.”
As we continue to face post-Brexit uncertainty, the experiences and survival strategies employed by the FSB in Northern Ireland offer valuable insights and, crucially, hope. Roger Pollen’s experiences highlight the importance of advocacy, strategic planning, and flexibility when facing a post-Brexit landscape. Gibraltar’s small businesses can perhaps draw from these lessons to start finding some sense in the uncertainty and thrive regardless.
SHARE THIS
OTHER
The world of work is undergoing a significant transformation, driven by the accelerating capabilities of Generative AI. While robots taking over our jobs might be a sci-fi trope, AI’s ability to learn, create, and automate tasks is undeniably impacting various industries. Generative AI is the umbrella term used to describe the type of AI that can create new content and ideas. This can include text, images, music, code and other types of content. We are now seeing how powerful this tool can be. But is this a threat or a powerful tool waiting to be harnessed? We set out to find out, what does the use of Generative AI look like in Gibraltar?
Starting and running a small business is rewarding but comes with its fair share of challenges. The path of entrepreneurship is often characterised by immense dedication, long hours, and tough decisions. As a small business owner, you're not just responsible for the operations and growth of your company and team, but also for your own wellbeing.
3 mins |
How to: Brainstorm
If you’ve been dreaming of starting your own business, you’re not alone. Data from the UK’s Office for National Statistics (ONS) revealed that the annual number of companies registered is edging closer to the one million mark, that’s up by 75,000 in 2022 which itself was 30,000 higher than in 2021. Whether it's following a passion, aiming for financial independence, or breaking free from the 9-5 grind, every entrepreneurial journey begins with one crucial thing: a solid idea. But coming up with that perfect idea can be tough. This is where brainstorming comes in—it’s the creative springboard that can help you turn your business dreams into reality.
Artificial Intelligence promises unprecedented opportunities for small business owners in Gibraltar. As the digital landscape faces constant evolution, understanding AI becomes not just beneficial but essential for businesses aiming to thrive in 2024. In this article, we aim to demystify the complexities surrounding AI, offering an approachable guide to its fundamentals, history, and practical applications for businesses, providing you with the knowledge to embrace this technology confidently.
We all have bad days, right? In business, that can mean we don’t bring our A-game to work and perhaps our service slips. Maybe a dish takes too long to reach a table or a staff member sounds distracted at the till. This could lead to negative Google Reviews or on ‘that’ Facebook group that […]
With its largely service-based economy, you'd be forgiven for thinking that Gibraltar didn't have to deal with the problem of toxic waste, perhaps more commonly seen in countries reliant on manufacturing, mining and even agriculture. However, every gaming company, insurance firm, fintech organisation, retailer, restaurant, and literally every other business on the Rock is potentially responsible for producing a particularly nasty waste byproduct - e-waste.
AI is poised to reshape the legal profession, with 31% of law firm leaders predicting major disruption by 2025. Scott Simmons explores how AI could improve client outcomes, streamline workflows, and drive value. Whether you’re cautious or curious, it’s time to explore AI’s potential.
If you’re looking to grow your business, expand your reach post Treaty or simply try something new, collaboration can be one of the most effective ways to do it. The key is approaching it with a bit of structure. And resisting the urge to say yes to everything just because someone seemed nice over a […]
We recently provided a large local organisation with their uniforms. Once the order was delivered, I felt compelled to send them guidelines on how to take care of their uniform. Spending money on clothes and footwear is not a guarantee on making the right impression, either to yourself, nor anyone else- it’s attention to detail that seals the deal.
Stepping into a leadership role can be exciting. It’s a chance to shape the future and lead a team to success. But with a leadership role comes a new level of responsibility. You’re suddenly the person others look to for direction and answers, and it’s your role to create a workplace where they can thrive - while also being accountable for their work. And that isn’t always an easy balancing act. Leadership is a learning curve - an eternal one at that. By focusing on a few key behaviours and techniques, you can set yourself on the right path to lead well, build a great high performing team and help your business grow.
The Treaty between the EU and the UK over Gibraltar is finally giving us some clarity, and yet, it also reminds us just how much sits outside our control. The finer details will take months to surface. Political tides may shift. Promises will be tested by practicalities. Every day, we face issues beyond our reach: new legislation, competitor actions, market trends, customer behaviour, staff turnover, illness, family responsibilities, global events. All of it lives in what Stephen Covey calls the Circle of Concern - things we care about, but cannot directly change. The more we fixate on them, the more frustration can grow.
2 mins |
Business Plan Essentials
You have a brilliant idea. You can picture the logo, the customers, maybe even the first sale. But without a clear plan for how to get there, the idea risks staying exactly that - an idea. Starting a business without a plan is like setting off on a trip with no map. You might eventually arrive somewhere, but it is unlikely to be where you hoped. A business plan is not just paperwork. When written with care, it is a roadmap that guides every decision, a pitch that wins support, and a source of confidence on the days when challenges mount.
Imposter syndrome is a psychological behaviour where individuals, including many high achievers, struggle with persistent feelings of self-doubt, inadequacy, or the fear of being exposed as a fraud. Despite their achievements, those experiencing imposter syndrome believe they are undeserving of their success or worry that they've misled others into overestimating their abilities.
Whether you’re an ebook tapper or traditional page turner, there are thousands of books that can make you better at business. Áine Panter, Head of the School of Business at the University of Gibraltar has curated a list of must-reads that will inspire, inform, and equip you for success.
After teaching in schools for 18 years I decided to take the plunge and embark on a self-employed life. Driven by my passion for teaching children with special educational needs I set out to discover alternative ways to make education accessible to all. My vision was to have the individual in mind, with their own strengths and challenges, and with that came the birth of ‘edYOUcation Clare Francis’; bringing the YOU into learning.
Success doesn’t just happen; it’s built on a strong foundation of preparation, clarity, and taking consistent action. Whether you’re launching a new business, taking your current side-hustle full-time, or looking to scale in a competitive market, having the right plan in place is essential.
Since 2007, Earth Hour has been known as the biggest hour for the planet as millions of people switch their “lights off” as a symbolic action for the environment
Eran Shay's journey is emblematic of the modern entrepreneur. A self-confessed ‘out-of-the-box’ thinker, he swapped a successful corporate career and a senior role at Deloitte to pursue his own projects and business opportunities.
In an increasingly digital work environment where we have more emails, WhatsApp messages & interruptions than ever before, many business leaders started looking at ways of alleviating the stress that comes with this increased workload. Relaxing the dress code and letting your team dress down and wear in more casual clothing is one way of doing this….Or is it?
Finding time to sit down with a book can feel like a luxury sometimes. We seem to be pulled in all sorts of directions, yet many of us still want to learn and stay exposed to new ideas. Podcasts have filled part of that gap. They’re accessible, conversational and easy to consume while commuting or […]