I see it all the time. A business pours energy into social media posts, flyers, maybe even a splashy event, and then wonders why the phone isn’t ringing. It’s easy to say the ‘marketing isn’t working’ than to go a little deeper into the reason why conversions aren’t up.

Very, very often, the issue isn’t the tactic. It’s the lack of a strategy.

In my work with businesses and organisations in Gibraltar and further afield, I’ve noticed a familiar pattern. Many teams leap straight into activity. New year, new flyers. Social posts queued. Events mapped out. There’s a rush to be visible. But when you ask what all of that activity is working towards, the answers are often fuzzy.

We know what we’re doing, but not always why we’re doing it.

The difference a strategy makes

One local organisation I’ve worked closely with is a business network that had already built strong foundations. It was doing good work and had an active member base. But its communications weren’t quite landing. Posts felt inconsistent. Engagement was hit and miss. The messaging had heart but lacked focus.

A change in leadership brought with it reflection. Its leadership looked at what the organisation stood for, what it wanted to grow, and who it needed to reach. That reflection turned into a sharper strategy. Clearer messaging pillars. A tone that matched the energy of the people behind the brand. And a better rhythm across platforms.

A few months later, the change was visible. More engagement. More consistency. A stronger presence. But most importantly, the team behind it felt more confident in what they were saying, where they were saying it and why it was important.

That’s what strategy gives you. Clarity on direction and confidence on delivery.

Getting dressed with nowhere to go?

Last year, I had a conversation with a London-based company that had just finished a rebrand. The project itself was beautifully executed. The visuals were polished. The tone felt modern. The team had clearly invested time and money in getting it right.

But a few weeks after launch, things stalled. The website looked great, but nobody knew what to post next. The team kept asking each other how to “bring the brand to life,” but there was no answer. They’d spent the entire budget on the outfit and had no plan for where to wear it.

Getting dressed with nowhere to go is more common than you might think.

A rebrand is more than a look. It’s a shift in how a business shows up and speaks. If it’s not backed by a strategy for how, where and to whom you communicate, the momentum fades fast.

A strong strategy would have asked some vital questions at the start. Who are we trying to reach? What do we want them to understand or feel? How do we take this new identity and apply it in a way that builds trust and action? Without that plan, you’re left with surface-level change.

Why invest in strategy?

Closer to home, I worked with an established insurer in Gibraltar who had just undergone a business-wide transformation. The rebrand was part of a larger modernisation, and they understood early on that it wasn’t just a design challenge. It was about shifting perception, internally and externally.

We worked together to build a communications strategy that would help staff connect with the new brand first, before rolling it out more widely. We talked about tone. About the customers they wanted to attract and retain. About the balance between familiarity and change.

That reflection turned into action. Staff felt included. Customers saw consistency. And the investment in the brand was matched by an investment in how it would be communicated. It worked because the business gave itself time to think.

If you’re not sure, ask yourself this

Strategy doesn’t need to be overcomplicated. It just needs to be deliberate. If your team isn’t sure whether you have a strategy guiding your marketing and communications, try asking these questions:

Do we know what business goals our communications are supporting?

Can we explain who we’re speaking to and what we want them to do?

Do our channels feel joined up, or are we posting for the sake of it?

Have we agreed on a tone of voice, a message, or a point of view?

Are we measuring things that matter or just watching likes?

If the answers aren’t clear, it’s probably time to take a breath and sketch out a roadmap.

My five-step framework to get started

If you’re looking for structure, here’s a simple approach I often recommend to clients:

1. Start with the business goals
   Everything else should support these. Be clear about whether you’re focused on growth, retention, repositioning or something else.
2. Get to know your audiences
   Different messages resonate with different stakeholders. Be specific about who you want to reach and what they care about – these could be external and internal.
3. Define your core messages
   What do you want people to understand, remember or share? Align these with your business goals. A charity t-shirt day is ok, but how does this fit with your broader startegy – if someone was to follow your socials would they get a balanced view of what your business is about?
4. Choose the right channels
   You don’t need to be everywhere – I see this mistake often. Choose the platforms and formats that fit your message and audience best.
5. Set a rhythm and review
   Plan a sustainable flow of communication and check in regularly. What’s working? What needs adjusting?

The time is now

A strategy isn’t a luxury and this period gives us a rare opportunity. If you find yourself rushing, carve some time. If you’ve set goals for the business, ask whether your communications have a plan to match. If not, start small by answering the five questions above as honestly as you can. Go on, what wait? I’ll end by quoting 90s electro legends Moloko… The Time is Now.

David Revagliatte is the founder of Motion, a communications and marketing agency specialising in strategy-led solutions for brands and organisations.